Why It’s Time to Scrap Business Rates for Small Businesses
Running a small business is hard enough without getting a bill based on the building you need to work in, rather than how well your business is doing.
At Just Jigsaws, we believe business rates are overdue for a rethink—and genuinely small businesses should be taken out of the system altogether.
Governments talk about supporting British manufacturing, saving our high streets and encouraging family businesses. Removing a fixed cost that can bear little relationship to profitability would be a practical place to start.
A workshop isn’t a sign of wealth
In England, business rates are based on a property’s rateable value, rather than the profit of the business occupying it. A business can therefore face a bill even when trading is difficult.
For manufacturers like us, that matters.
We need space for machinery, timber, puzzles, packing and people. We need room to work safely and somewhere to store the things we make.
We can’t move the saws into the spare bedroom or ask the timber to work from home.
A workshop might look sizeable from the outside. That doesn’t tell you what’s left in the bank after wages, materials, energy and everything else have been paid.
The space is part of how we earn a living. It isn’t evidence that we’re rolling in money.
The bills don’t get smaller when the order book does
Small businesses live with uncertainty every day.
A customer postpones an order. A payment arrives late. A machine needs repairing. Work you’ve relied on for years suddenly moves overseas.
You adjust, work longer hours and try to find a way through.
But fixed costs don’t politely step aside while you recover.
That’s the problem with a tax that doesn’t automatically respond to your trading position. It adds pressure when a business may already be fighting to protect jobs and keep the doors open.
Removing business rates wouldn’t solve every challenge. But for small firms that pay them, it could provide valuable breathing room.
Small business relief helps, but it isn’t the whole answer
There is already small business rate relief in England. Eligible businesses can receive reductions, with the amount depending on their property’s rateable value and the eligibility rules.
That help matters. But it doesn’t answer the underlying question.
Why should the rental value of a building play such a large part in deciding whether a small business can afford to contribute?
A manufacturer may need substantial floor space while working on modest margins. Another business may need very little space and earn considerably more.
A fairer system should recognise that difference.
Let us invest in the business
At Just Jigsaws, our family has been making wooden puzzles in Derbyshire since 1973.
Three generations of work, learning and determination have gone into keeping that going.
Like plenty of small businesses, we’re constantly thinking about what comes next. New designs. New customers. Better equipment. More efficient ways of working.
Those things need investment.
Money that stays in a small business could help repair a machine, train an employee, improve wages or build a reserve for a difficult month.
Sometimes growth starts with something far less glamorous than a government strategy: being able to afford the equipment you need without wondering which other bill will have to wait.
We still need properly funded local services
Scrapping business rates for small businesses would have a cost. Pretending otherwise wouldn’t help the argument.
Councils and public services need reliable funding, and businesses depend on them too.
Any replacement would need a properly funded plan, clear eligibility rules and safeguards against large companies splitting themselves into smaller businesses to claim an exemption.
There should also be a gradual transition as firms grow, so taking on more work or moving into larger premises doesn’t create a sudden financial cliff edge.
These are details that need serious work. They shouldn’t be an excuse to avoid reform altogether.
A small business is more than an occupied building
When a family business closes, the loss reaches beyond its owners.
Employees lose work. Suppliers lose a customer. Communities lose skills, experience and people who have spent years contributing to the place they call home.
In manufacturing, those losses can be difficult to reverse.
Once the machinery is sold and the skilled team has moved on, you can’t simply turn the lights back on and pick up where you left off.
Keeping viable businesses going should matter more than preserving an outdated way of taxing the space they need.
Give small businesses a fair chance
We’re not asking the government to run Just Jigsaws for us.
We’ll make the puzzles, develop the designs, find the customers and sweep up the sawdust. There’s always plenty of that last job.
What we want is a system that understands the reality of being a small manufacturer.
If Britain wants thriving high streets, busy workshops and family businesses that last another generation, it needs to make room for them to succeed.
Scrapping business rates for genuinely small businesses would be a meaningful start.
Because having a roof over your workshop shouldn’t be mistaken for having money to spare.